Support the work
← OSAP opinion & analysis

OpinionOSAP-002 · OSAP commentary2 min read

Who is checking the Ministry?

Ontario says KPMG is reviewing OSAP. Students deserve to know whether the review also checks the Ministry’s own decisions.

By Jason WiltonUpdated Opinion · Jason Wilton’s view of the sources linked below.
Jump to a section

Who is examining what?

An audit checks how something was handled. The public needs to know which decisions are being checked, including the Ministry’s own role.

The Ministry’s October 20 statement describes a sector-wide investigation supported by KPMG, which it calls an independent third-party auditor. In his November 2 speech, Minister Nolan Quinn also said the Auditor General had been notified in early October.

READING ONTARIO’S WORDS

What was said? What changes for a student?

Every explanation starts with the dated official source.

  1. The words

    Read the statement.

    See who said it, when they said it and where it was published.

  2. The practical question

    Look for an answer you can use.

    Can a student apply, receive a payment or meet the next deadline?

  3. Our explanation

    Follow the source and the reasoning.

    We explain the statement in plain English and label our analysis and opinion.

    Read the OSAP commentary

A student needs to know what happens next.

What will the Auditor General examine?

Quinn says the Auditor General received information in early October. The next useful detail is what the office will examine and report.

The Auditor General’s office explains that it considers public and MPP information when selecting audits and may initiate a special audit. Receiving information and announcing an audit are different steps.

The government says outside experts are helping it fix the problems. But who is checking the people responsible for overseeing the system?

  • Does the review check the Ministry’s decisions as well as what colleges did?
  • Can the public read what the reviewers were hired to check?
  • Which findings will be published, when, and with what explanation for anything withheld?

What would answer the concern.

I want to see what KPMG was hired to check and what the Auditor General says its office will examine. The public should be able to follow both.

What I want is a clear map of the work: who is examining which decisions, and what the public will get to see. That is the explanation the word audit should lead to.

READ NEXT

They voted against an independent audit. We still want answers.

Opinion3 min read

By Jason

Read the family’s response to the committee vote on an independent OSAP audit, with links to the recorded vote and official sources.

Read this article

Also worth reading

Sources & notes.

These are the public sources examined for this note. A dated statement records what was said at that time; later information may change the practical answer.

  1. Ministry statement · October 20, 2026

    The Ministry describes its investigation and KPMG’s supporting role.

  2. Official House transcript · November 2, 2026

    Quinn’s Opposition Day speech records his account of Auditor General notification.

  3. Auditor General of Ontario · Public requests

    Explains how the office receives public information, selects audits and may begin a special audit.

Publication & revisions
Note
OSAP-002
Byline
Jason Wilton
First published
Permanent link
Link to OSAP-002
  1. — First published. Analysis of the dated public sources linked below.
  2. — Simplified the wording and changed the headline to ask who is checking the Ministry’s decisions. Original sources and publication date retained.

Jason Wilton. “Who is checking the Ministry?” OSAP opinion & analysis, OSAP-002, November 3, 2026.